People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Still dreaming of this pizza, seriously the best in the Milwaukee area. Make sure to call ahead to reserve a spot or pick up order. They make a finite amount of pizzas a night, which shows just how dedicated they are to the craft. The staff were so nice and welcoming, really had a magical time here and cant wait to come again. ”
“ Finally picked up pizzas from here after having it on our list since we moved to Tosa almost three years ago. Absolutely lived up to the hype. Amazing flavors and crust and just all around phenomenal pizza. This is our new goto pizza spot for sure. Thank you! Update can confirm this pizza is delicious when eaten straight from the fridge the next day, which I think we can agree is really the true test of how yummy a pizza is, right? ”
“ Really great crust and tasty topping combos. We ordered both a red and a white the Cape Blanco and the Hot Marmot. Both were very good. If youre doing takeaway it doesnt hurt to have fresh mozzarella or a burrata on hand with extra olive oil to make best use of the delicious crusts. ”
“ Best crust and best pizza in Milwaukee. Cant believe I havent rated it yet. The couple that owns and runs the place are very friendly and welcoming. They rotate pizza choices throughout the year so when you go will dictate which of the special pizzas are available. Great beer list and always the best background music, too! ”
“ Must stop pizza joint! They run different types of pizzas throughout the seasons so it never gets old and the pizzas are always top notch. We definitely couldnt finish it all but its just as good later as it was with the first bite! ”
“ Guys! This is a MUST TRY pizza place. The crust is perfect, chewy on the inside with a crispy outside. The sauce is light and seasoned to perfection. We went with the sausage, mushroom, and onion, but I wish I couldve tried them all. This is my new FAVORITE pizza! ”
“ We called ahead for a scheduled pickup, and they were absolutely wonderful over the phone helping us with our order. We ordered a large Hogsback Sausage and Red Onion. The pizza was ready when we arrived, and the service was excellent. Parking was easy, and they take credit cards. The crust was perfect, and the pizza was so good we just kept eating one slice after another. We finished the whole pie under 15 minutes and then felt totally guilty about how fast we inhaled the pizza. This is easily on our Top 5 Pizza Places of Milwaukee List. ”
“ Some of the best pizzas we have ever had! The service is great, and the pizza is far superior to any others in the near vicinity. This is not tavern style and more closely imitates a napoletana Italian crust. A much needed food style for the neighborhood! ”
Menu
Goat Rocks Pizza
$22.00Sugar Snap Pea Salad
$7.00Sassy Cow White Milk
$2.00Sassy Cow Chocolate Milk
$2.00Floats
$5.00
About
Wy'east Pizza
Welcome to the vibrant world of Wy'east Pizza, a delightful culinary gem nestled in Milwaukee at 5601 W Vliet St. Known for its mouth-watering creations, this pizzeria doesn't just serve pizza; it crafts experiences, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike.
What sets Wy'east Pizza apart? It is all in their dedication to quality and creativity. Their unique offerings, like the Goat Rocks Pizza with asparagus, goat cheese, and a special blend of seasonings, truly elevate the traditional pizza experience. Every bite bursts with flavor, ideal for adventurous eaters. The Hot Marmot Pizza, featuring pepperoni and Mama Lil's sweet hot peppers, balances spice and texture flawlessly, showcasing their mastery in pizza-making.
- Reservations: It's recommended to reserve your spot, as they craft a limited number of pizzas each night, emphasizing their commitment to quality over quantity.
- Vegan and Vegetarian Options: With a good selection of vegan and vegetarian pizzas, there’s something for everyone, proving that great taste knows no dietary restrictions.
- Relaxed Atmosphere: The casual setting with outdoor seating makes it perfect for families and groups, ensuring a welcoming vibe for all. The restaurant also boasts gender-neutral restrooms and is wheelchair accessible.
- Payment Flexibility: Customers can conveniently pay using Android Pay, Apple Pay, credit cards, or even cryptocurrency, making it accessible for everyone.
- Community Vibe: The staff are renowned for their friendliness and willingness to provide a magical dining experience, as many reviews have highlighted.
Beyond just delightful pizzas, Wy'east offers refreshing salads that beautifully complement their main dishes. For instance, the Sugar Snap Pea Salad with feta and mint is a refreshing palate cleanser perfect alongside a rich pizza.
But don’t just take my word for it; customer reviews echo the dedication to excellence at Wy'east Pizza. With patrons delighted by the crust’s texture and the chef's innovative topping combinations, it’s clear this establishment has mastered the art of pizza. Guests like Bridget Williams rave about the magical experience and their commitment to a finite number of pizzas, while Erin Phillips' updates confirm the joy of eating their pizza straight from the fridge the next day, attesting to its quality.
In a market flooded with pizza joints, Wy'east Pizza stands tall with its creative flavors, welcoming ambiance, and dedication to craft. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or opting for delivery, you’re assured an unforgettable experience that stays with you long after you leave. Make sure to make this your next pizza stop—you won’t regret it!
Book a table